Identi.ca proves me wrong, and I’m happy about it

The big buzz today is around Indenti.ca, a new open source, and open platform microblogging service. That the code is open source is great in itself, but the biggest breakthrough is support for the new OpenMicroBlogging standard, which means that in theory, anyone could host the script and each service would talk to each other, creating a distributed, decentralized Twitter.

Dave Winer has been talking about something like this for months, and a while back I wrote on another site that while it was a great idea, it wouldn’t happen, because no one would build an open platform like this because the economics of doing so didn’t add up. After all, if you’re a startup, with funding, why would you build something that others could take and use, possibly (and likely) to bypass the startup in the medium to long term. Centralized services are popular for a reason: it keeps people coming back to the destination site.

I was wrong. Someone has done it. The folks behind Identi.ca have done it, and I couldn’t be happier.

There’s already a lot of discussion around Identi.ca v Twitter in relation to features and usability, and I get a lot of the negative sentiment. Identi.ca as a stand alone service is basic at best, and perhaps I’d even go as far as calling it fairly lame, as the current version isn’t exactly exciting for the end user. But that’s irrelevant in the bigger picture. Even if Identi.ca and Laconi.ca code that runs it turns out to be complete failures, it has achieved one thing: it proves that open source, decentralized microblogging is possible, and that it can be done.

It’s way to early to make a call on the code and the OpenMicroBlogging standard at this time, and even then I’m no expert in code so I’m not remotely qualified to make a call on where it is at, although I will be playing with it shortly. But I can call it a start. As I described it in a FriendFeed thread, it’s a freedom seed, the start of something much bigger at a time the market is desperately seeking alternatives as the Twitter train wreck keeps on chugging. The only question now is how quickly will new sites pop up that run this code, providing improved consumer choice and driving the open source project forward so that it may one day fully compete with Twitter, and then eventually pass it.

More on The Inquisitr here.

Comments

11 responses to “Identi.ca proves me wrong, and I’m happy about it”

  1. charlieanzman Avatar

    Duncan – You really have to stop starting these Wednesday night parties

  2. […] what I’ve read so far, identi.ca is “surprisingly easy” and a “freedom seed.” That may be true, but one thing it isn’t is a distributed Twitter. It is open source, […]

  3. […] here. The Inquisitr’s coverage here, and a more informal post I wrote on my personal blog here. addthis_url = […]

  4. […] uncanriley.com, StartupNorth, VentureBeat, SheGeeks, Maple Leaf 2.0, sarahintampa, The Inquisitr, Webomatica, Stay N’ Alive, Industry Standard, TomsTechBlog.com, evan, blackrimglasses.com and Ross Mayfield’s Weblog […]

  5. […] each other just like we were using the same service from the same provider."Technology pundit Duncan Riley says the biggest breakthrough is "support for the new OpenMicroBlogging standard, which means […]

  6. […] Why It Could Blow Twitter Away [nw] :: SheGeeks Identi.ca: Twitter Alternative [nw] :: webomatica Identi.ca proves me wrong, and I?¢‚Ǩ‚Ñ¢m happy about it [nw] :: Duncan […]

  7. Medela metro bag Avatar

    Thanks for the post, it's not exactly what I thought!

  8. Medela metro bag Avatar

    Thanks for the post, it's not exactly what I thought!

  9. nike shox Avatar

    I read your profile today and it was so good to me.i feel you are the only one missing in my entire life so i decided to stop on and let you know that i am interested to be a friend first.When the fight begins within himself, a man's worth something

  10. nike shox Avatar

    I read your profile today and it was so good to me.i feel you are the only one missing in my entire life so i decided to stop on and let you know that i am interested to be a friend first.When the fight begins within himself, a man's worth something

  11. nike shox Avatar

    I read your profile today and it was so good to me.i feel you are the only one missing in my entire life so i decided to stop on and let you know that i am interested to be a friend first.When the fight begins within himself, a man's worth something

Leave a Reply